Thursday, September 25, 2014
The Anointed and the Tragic Visions
The good and the bad exist in our society and in our government.
What we have now in our government is a clash of visions as Tom Sowell
defines it in his book Intellectuals and Society. The current dominant
vision is that of what was labeled "the vision of the anointed". In
this vision, elites, largely self-anointed, hold the principle influence and direction of
our government across a wide swath of issues. I called this the "authoritarian
vision" in a recent post, because the elites want what amounts to
expanded, even dictatorial, powers to use their presumed knowledge and superior
intellect to create laws and govern the nation. In this anointed vision, our
current Constitution is merely a hindrance to the objectives of the elites, and
it needs to be changed to suit their unique and not publically voted upon vision.
The opposing vision is labeled by Sowell the "tragic vision",
which is the "traditional vision" I defined earlier, that most of us
hold dear. This vision considers the basis of our government to be contained in
the Constitution and civil or common law, and which makes effective representation
of the people, checks and balances throughout government and our mediating
institutions central and indispensible features to counter the potential
excesses of those in power. The written Constitution ensures that every citizen
knows the fundamental law of the land.
It is a tragic vision simply because it recognizes the tragic need for
protection of the people from the elites and the power-hungry progressives---
those who would be king---and those that would make drastic changes to our
government in the name of their anointed vision of efficiency and amorality! Tragic
also because it recognizes that all men are fallible, and a fallible man or
group of men with power to dictate laws and sweeping regulations is a serious
existential problem for this democratic republic.
The good things in our society are from the traditional, tragic vision for
our democratic republic.
The bad things are from the vision of the self-proclaimed intellectual anointeds
which is an anathema to our way of life.
For a more complete listing of the good and bad ideas prevalent today see my post of July 18, 2014 entitled Conservatism: Simple to Complex.
Tom Sowell wrote 669 pages with notes in his book Intellectuals and Society to explain why intellectuals and their "vision of the anointed" (and my version of the authoritarian vision) are highly detrimental to our nation and to individual citizens as well. So I strongly suggest that everyone reads this masterful work.
What we have now in our government is a clash of visions as Tom Sowell defines it in his book Intellectuals and Society. The current dominant vision is that of what was labeled "the vision of the anointed". In this vision, elites, largely self-anointed, hold the principle influence and direction of our government across a wide swath of issues. I called this the "authoritarian vision" in a recent post, because the elites want what amounts to expanded, even dictatorial, powers to use their presumed knowledge and superior intellect to create laws and govern the nation. In this anointed vision, our current Constitution is merely a hindrance to the objectives of the elites, and it needs to be changed to suit their unique and not publically voted upon vision.
The opposing vision is labeled by Sowell the "tragic vision", which is the "traditional vision" I defined earlier, that most of us hold dear. This vision considers the basis of our government to be contained in the Constitution and civil or common law, and which makes effective representation of the people, checks and balances throughout government and our mediating institutions central and indispensible features to counter the potential excesses of those in power. The written Constitution ensures that every citizen knows the fundamental law of the land.
It is a tragic vision simply because it recognizes the tragic need for protection of the people from the elites and the power-hungry progressives--- those who would be king---and those that would make drastic changes to our government in the name of their anointed vision of efficiency and amorality! Tragic also because it recognizes that all men are fallible, and a fallible man or group of men with power to dictate laws and sweeping regulations is a serious existential problem for this democratic republic.
The good things in our society are from the traditional, tragic vision for our democratic republic.
The bad things are from the vision of the self-proclaimed intellectual anointeds which is an anathema to our way of life.
For a more complete listing of the good and bad ideas prevalent today see my post of July 18, 2014 entitled Conservatism: Simple to Complex.
Tom Sowell wrote 669 pages with notes in his book Intellectuals and Society to explain why intellectuals and their "vision of the anointed" (and my version of the authoritarian vision) are highly detrimental to our nation and to individual citizens as well. So I strongly suggest that everyone reads this masterful work.
Post a Comment